This review dives into the Urban Decay All Nighter Ultra Matte Setting Spray, specifically examining its effectiveness for those with oily skin. The author meticulously tests the spray over two days, using both liquid and powder foundations, to assess its oil-control claims and overall performance. The review details the application process, highlighting unexpected issues and challenges encountered throughout the testing period. Particular attention is paid to the spray's ability to prevent shine, maintain makeup longevity, and its impact on the overall look and feel of the makeup application. Ultimately, the review aims to determine whether this popular setting spray lives up to its promises for individuals with oily complexions.This in-depth analysis explores the positive and negative aspects of the Urban Decay All Nighter Ultra Matte Setting Spray, offering a candid assessment of its suitability for oily skin. The author shares their personal experience, including unexpected problems with white residue and makeup lifting, providing a realistic perspective on the product's performance. Readers will find a detailed account of both the short-term and long-term effects of the setting spray, culminating in a final verdict and recommendation. This review is designed to help those with oily skin make an informed decision before purchasing this relatively expensive product.
Read more: 5 Best Vitamin C Setting Sprays for Flawless Makeup
First Impressions & Application
Upon initial application, I noticed small white dots appearing on my face. This is a common issue with some setting sprays, but usually blends away easily. However, with the Urban Decay All Nighter Ultra Matte, this was not the case.
My beauty blender actually picked up my foundation as I tried to blend it out, causing a significant issue. This was unexpected and led to needing extra steps in my makeup routine to correct the problem.
To resolve the white dots, I used a translucent setting powder to blend everything together. However, I later discovered more white dots on my hair and clothing, which proved extremely difficult to remove even after several attempts.
10-Hour Wear Test - Day 1 (Liquid Foundation)
For the first day's test, I used liquid foundation. Despite the initial application issues, I wanted to see the spray's long-term performance.
After ten hours, my oils began to show through, particularly in my cheek area. This is despite the spray's claims of 16-hour wear and a matte finish.
While the spray initially provided a matte look, it ultimately failed to control shine completely for the duration of the test. The drying sensation was noticeable but not overly uncomfortable.
10-Hour Wear Test - Day 2 (Powder Foundation)
On the second day, I used a hydrating powder foundation to further test the spray's oil-control capabilities. This presented an additional challenge due to the foundation's moisturizing properties.
The setting spray lifted my powder foundation in places, making this even worse than day one. Despite using more powder foundation to correct the lifted areas, it still didn't fully address the issue.
After 10 hours, significant oil was present on the side of my face without the spray, while the side with the spray remained matte but still showed some oil breakout. The foundation was patchy due to lifting.
Final Verdict
The Urban Decay All Nighter Ultra Matte Setting Spray failed to meet my expectations for oily skin. While it does provide a matte finish and controls shine for a time, it caused significant makeup lifting and left behind white residue that was nearly impossible to remove.
At $33, the product isn't worth the hassle and problems it causes, especially the issues with lifting foundation and leaving behind white dots on clothes and hair.
I would not recommend this setting spray for those with oily skin. There are better options available on the market that provide superior oil control without these negative side effects.