Choosing the right setting spray can make or break your makeup look. This head-to-head comparison pits two industry giants against each other: Urban Decay's All Nighter and Benefit's Porefessional Super Setter. Both promise all-day wear and flawless results, but their approaches and final effects differ significantly. We put these popular setting sprays to the test, subjecting them to a rigorous, real-world evaluation to determine which reigns supreme in terms of longevity, finish, and overall performance. This showdown will reveal which spray truly delivers on its claims and which one emerges as the ultimate winner for achieving a perfect, long-lasting makeup look.This detailed review explores the key differences between Urban Decay All Nighter and Benefit Porefessional Super Setter, examining their application, finish, oil control, and longevity throughout a full day of wear. We delve into the pros and cons of each, analyzing the texture, feel, and impact on various skin types. Ultimately, we aim to provide you with a clear and comprehensive comparison to help you make an informed decision about which setting spray best suits your needs and preferences. Prepare for the ultimate setting spray showdown!
Read more: 5 Best Vitamin C Setting Sprays for Flawless Makeup
Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray: The OG
Urban Decay's All Nighter setting spray is a cult classic, renowned for its long-lasting hold and impressive claim of up to 16 hours of wear. This 118ml bottle retails at a price point that reflects its popularity. The spray boasts temperature control technology, promising to keep your makeup cool and prevent that dreaded midday oily shine.
The fine mist is easily applied, and the formula claims to prevent smudging, fading, and settling into fine lines. Many consider it a heavyweight champion in the setting spray arena, capable of withstanding even the longest days.
Benefit Porefessional Super Setter: The Lightweight Contender
Benefit's Porefessional Super Setter is a 120ml bottle, also claiming up to 16 hours of wear but at a slightly different price point. Unlike the All Nighter, it's alcohol-free, making it a gentler option for sensitive skin.
This setting spray features pore-blurring powders for a smoother, more refined finish. It's designed to lock makeup in place while providing a weightless feel and an instant mattifying effect – a key differentiator from the All Nighter's natural finish.
Application and Initial Impressions
Applying the All Nighter yielded a powerful, almost overwhelming mist, leaving my skin feeling noticeably damp. The spray felt potent and provided a natural, rather than mattified, finish. I found myself unintentionally spraying my hair!
In contrast, the Benefit spray was exceptionally lightweight and gentle, barely felt on the skin. It provided an immediate mattifying effect, visibly smoothing my skin and minimizing the appearance of pores. The difference in application was striking.
6-Hour Check-in: The Midday Mark
After six hours, both sprays showed impressive results. The Urban Decay All Nighter controlled oil exceptionally well, maintaining a flawless makeup look with minimal shine. There was no caking or settling.
The Benefit spray also controlled oil effectively, boasting even less shine than the All Nighter, particularly on the forehead. My skin looked remarkably smooth, almost poreless, with makeup appearing fresh.
10-Hour Final Verdict: The Champion is...
Ten hours in, and both setting sprays still held up remarkably. While both controlled oil well, the Urban Decay All Nighter showed slightly more oil breakthrough on the cheeks and nose.
The Benefit Porefessional Super Setter emerged as the victor due to its exceptional pore-minimizing and mattifying effects. While the All Nighter offered excellent longevity and controlled oil beautifully, the Benefit spray's gentler, alcohol-free formula and superior smoothing capabilities made it the winner of this showdown.