Choosing the right setting spray can make or break your makeup look. Milani offers two popular options: Make It Dewy and Make It Last. Both promise to extend the wear of your makeup, but cater to different preferences. Make It Last aims for a flawless matte finish, while Make It Dewy promises a radiant, dewy glow. This detailed comparison dives into the performance of each spray, examining their drying times, finishes, and overall impact on makeup longevity. We’ll explore whether these marketed differences translate into real-world results.This review features a side-by-side comparison, applying one spray to each half of the face to observe any distinctions in application, drying time, and how the makeup holds up over several hours. We'll assess not only the immediate effects but also the long-term performance of both sprays. Our goal is to provide a comprehensive understanding of each product, helping you decide which Milani setting spray—Make It Dewy or Make It Last—best suits your unique needs and desired makeup finish.
Read more: 5 Best Vitamin C Setting Sprays for Flawless Makeup
Product Overview and Expectations
This review compares Milani's Make It Dewy and Make It Last setting sprays. Both promise to extend makeup wear, but one aims for a dewy finish, while the other targets a matte look. I've used Make It Last before, but this is my first time trying Make It Dewy. My goal is to determine if the marketed differences hold true in real-world application and longevity.
I'm curious to see how both sprays perform over several hours, noting any differences in their drying time, finish, and overall effect on makeup. This comparison will focus on the practical aspects, helping you decide which spray better suits your needs and preferences.
Application and Initial Impressions
After applying my usual makeup routine (foundation, concealer, blush, etc.), I applied Make It Dewy to one side of my face and Make It Last to the other. The application process was fairly standard for both sprays.
Immediately, I noticed a key difference: Make It Dewy took significantly longer to dry than Make It Last. Make It Last provided an instant matte finish, while Make It Dewy remained noticeably wet for quite some time. This initial observation aligns with the products' marketed claims.
Long-Term Wear Test and Results
I waited approximately four hours to assess the longevity of each spray. After the waiting period, both sprays exhibited minimal makeup transfer or fading.
Interestingly, despite the initial differences in drying time and finish, there was little visible difference in the overall look of the makeup after four hours. Both sides maintained a similar level of freshness and coverage.
Final Verdict and Recommendations
While Make It Dewy's longer drying time might be a drawback for some, it ultimately delivers a comparable result to Make It Last in terms of makeup longevity. The choice depends on personal preference regarding finish.
If you prefer a matte look and need a quick-drying setting spray, Make It Last is a better option. However, if you desire a dewy finish and don't mind the extended drying time, Make It Dewy is a perfectly viable choice. Both products are effective for extending the wear of makeup.