This review compares the old and new formulas of Make Up For Ever's Mist & Fix setting spray, analyzing whether the updated version justifies an upgrade. We delve into key differences, including size, price, and shelf life, to determine if the reformulation offers significant improvements in performance. A side-by-side application test examines the spray nozzle's functionality, setting time, and overall makeup longevity throughout a six-hour wear test.The comparison considers both immediate application differences and long-term wear, evaluating the setting spray's impact on makeup staying power under normal and humid conditions. Ultimately, this review aims to provide a comprehensive assessment to help consumers decide whether to switch to the newer formula or stick with the original, or perhaps explore alternative setting sprays altogether. We'll uncover if the extended shelf life and slight price reduction outweigh any potential compromises in application or performance.
Read more: 5 Best Vitamin C Setting Sprays for Flawless Makeup
Packaging and Price Differences
The most immediate difference between the old and new Make Up For Ever Mist & Fix setting sprays is their size. The new version is noticeably smaller, holding 3.38 fluid ounces compared to the old one's 4.22 fluid ounces. This size reduction also impacts the price; the older spray retailed for $31, while the newer version is priced at $28. While a smaller size contributes to the price difference, it’s important to note the difference in shelf life.
Beyond size and cost, there's a significant change in shelf life. The original formula boasted a six-month shelf life, whereas the new formula boasts a longer 12-month shelf life. This suggests a potential reformulation of ingredients to extend the product’s usability.
Application and Initial Impressions
For the comparison, I applied the old formula to one half of my face and the new formula to the other. Immediately, the spray nozzle stood out as a difference; the new spray nozzle's performance was less desirable, producing a less even mist and feeling harsher on the skin. The older spray provided a more comfortable and uniform application.
Despite the less-than-ideal application of the new formula, I quickly assessed the initial setting properties of each spray. Interestingly, the old formula seemed to set more quickly on the skin, while the new spray required additional fanning and blending with a sponge for seamless integration into the makeup.
Long-Term Wear Test and Results
After applying both formulas and completing my makeup, I wore the makeup for approximately six hours to assess long-term wear. Following this period, surprisingly, both sides of my face looked virtually identical, suggesting little to no difference in the staying power of each formula. This indicates that either the formulas are very similar or the reformulation hasn't significantly altered the setting properties.
Even on a hot and humid day, the makeup remained in place, exhibiting typical shine in the center of my face, a common occurrence regardless of the setting spray used. The overall performance of both formulas was consistent, confirming that there isn't a noticeable superior formula.
Conclusion and Final Verdict
Ultimately, the new Make Up For Ever Mist & Fix formula doesn't offer a dramatic improvement over its predecessor. While the price is slightly lower and the shelf life is extended, the smaller size and slightly less-than-ideal spray nozzle are drawbacks. The performance of both formulas is remarkably similar in terms of setting and lasting power throughout the day.
Considering the minor differences and similar performance, upgrading isn't crucial. If you're already satisfied with the old formula, sticking with it is perfectly reasonable. However, if you're trying the brand for the first time, the new one is a solid option. If seeking alternatives, exploring other setting sprays might provide more noticeable improvements.