This review delves into the festive offerings from Yves Saint Laurent, focusing on two key products: the limited-edition Holiday Quad 910 eyeshadow palette and the reformulated Rouge Pur Couture lipsticks. We explore the performance and quality of each, providing detailed insights into their textures, pigmentation, and longevity. Particular attention is paid to the eyeshadow palette's blendability and the lipsticks' updated hydrating formula.The review also includes comparisons to similar products from competing brands, such as Suqqu, Chanel, Merit, and Armani, allowing for a broader perspective on the YSL offerings within the current market. We analyze the color stories, undertones, and overall finish of each product, helping readers determine if these luxurious items align with their individual preferences and budgetary considerations. Ultimately, the review aims to provide a comprehensive assessment of whether the YSL Holiday Quad 910 and Rouge Pur Couture lipsticks live up to their high-end reputation and are worth the investment.
Pros And Cons
- Smooth, creamy texture
- Easy to apply
- Opaque pigmentation
- Soft and blends easily
- Classic holiday color story
- Glitter shade can be messy
- Some fallout from glitter shade
- Comfortable on lips
- Hydrating
- Impressive wear time
- Leaves a stain
- Can feather or bleed
- Colors may appear warmer in real life than in promotional photos
Read more: Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk: 5 Must-Have Products
YSL Holiday Eyeshadow Quad 910: A Closer Look
The YSL Holiday Quad 910 is a limited-edition palette featuring four shades: a smooth, creamy silver; a glittery gold; a matte black with subtle sparkle; and a creamy matte soft pink. The textures are incredibly soft and blend effortlessly, although the gold glitter can be slightly messy.
Pigmentation is excellent across all shades, offering full coverage with minimal effort whether applied with a brush or fingers. The palette's color story is classic and festive, perfect for creating a glamorous smoky eye or a sparkly holiday look. The soft pink serves as a beautiful base to enhance the other shades.
Despite its luxurious feel, the palette's relatively small size (4 grams) and limited availability make it less accessible. While the quality is exceptional, the limited edition nature and price point might deter some buyers.
YSL Rouge Pur Couture Lipstick: A New Formula
The YSL Rouge Pur Couture lipsticks have undergone a reformulation, featuring updated packaging with a gold cap. The colors appear warmer in person than in promotional photos, a common occurrence with many makeup products.
Three shades were reviewed: Beige Trench (a nude with brown and peach undertones), Nude Decollete (a soft peach), and Blouse Nu (a warm rose). The formula feels slightly more hydrating than the previous version, offering a comfortable, satin finish.
The lipsticks provide impressive wear time, considering their smooth, glide-on texture and tendency towards feathering. Using a lip liner is recommended to prevent feathering and enhance longevity.
Comparison with Other Palettes and Lipsticks
The YSL Holiday Quad 910 was compared to similar palettes from Suqqu and Chanel, revealing that while the color stories aren't identical, they share a similar holiday-inspired aesthetic.
The YSL Rouge Pur Couture lipsticks were compared to shades from Merit and Armani, highlighting differences in pigmentation, texture, and undertones. The YSL shades leaned warmer, while some of the comparison shades were cooler-toned.
These comparisons offer alternative options for those seeking similar color palettes and lipstick finishes. The differences in texture and undertones highlight the importance of considering individual preferences when choosing makeup.
Conclusion: Are These Products Worth It?
The YSL Holiday Quad 910 offers a high-quality, luxurious eyeshadow experience with a classic holiday color story. However, its limited availability and price might be a deterrent for some. The formula is soft, blendable, and highly pigmented.
The reformulated YSL Rouge Pur Couture lipsticks provide a comfortable, satin finish with impressive longevity. The slightly more hydrating formula might be preferable to those who prefer a more comfortable wear. The color range offers both warm and potentially cool-toned options.
Overall, both the palette and lipsticks deliver on quality and performance. Whether they are 'worth it' depends on individual preferences and budget. The limited-edition nature of the palette might make it a collector's item for makeup enthusiasts.