The Too Faced Sweet Peach Eyeshadow Palette: a highly anticipated release that sparked an online frenzy, but did the product live up to the hype? This review dives deep into the Sweet Peach palette, examining its accessibility, packaging, shade range, and performance. We’ll explore the pigmentation and blendability of each of the 18 eyeshadows, comparing them to other popular Too Faced palettes like the Chocolate Bar and Semi-Sweet. We'll also analyze the overall wearability and vibrancy of the colors, offering a comprehensive assessment of its strengths and weaknesses.From the initial struggle to secure the palette amidst website crashes to the final makeup look created using its shades, this review provides a detailed account of the entire experience. We'll showcase high-quality swatches for each shade, providing a visual reference for potential buyers. Ultimately, this review aims to give you an honest and thorough evaluation of the Too Faced Sweet Peach Eyeshadow Palette, helping you determine whether it's the right addition to your makeup collection.
Pros And Cons
- Cute packaging
- 18 eyeshadows
- Buildable and blendable eyeshadows
- Pleasant peach scent (described as gummy bear-like)
- Good range of shades for neutral looks
- Some shades are subdued, requiring multiple applications for vibrancy
- Difficult to obtain initially (limited availability)
Read more: 5 Stunning Cool-Toned Eyeshadow Palettes You Need
The Hunt for Sweet Peach
Securing the Too Faced Sweet Peach Eyeshadow Palette proved more challenging than anticipated. Its initial release was plagued by website crashes and immediate sell-outs across various retailers like Ulta and Sephora. I had to resort to using the Ulta app to snag one, beating the rush on their website. The scarcity definitely dampened my initial excitement.
The online frenzy surrounding the palette’s launch highlighted its immense popularity, creating a sense of urgency and frustration for many eager buyers. This experience, however, unintentionally lowered my expectations before even opening the palette.
Palette Overview and Packaging
The Too Faced Sweet Peach Palette boasts 18 eyeshadows, each weighing 0.03 oz. This size is a happy medium, neither too tiny nor overly large. The packaging is undeniably charming, a thin tin with a magnetic closure and the shade names printed neatly inside. The included mirror is a practical addition.
The standard Too Faced look card is included, adding a touch of brand consistency. The overall aesthetic is undeniably appealing and fits perfectly with Too Faced's signature style, which is a key selling point for many customers.
Swatches and Shade Comparisons
The palette offers a diverse range of shades, from light peaches and creams to deeper, more intense hues. I've included swatches to showcase the pigmentation and texture of each shade, allowing for easier comparison with other Too Faced palettes like the original Chocolate Bar, Semi-Sweet, and Bon Bon.

The comparison shots highlight the similarities and differences in shade ranges across these palettes. This provides a helpful visual reference for those considering purchasing the Sweet Peach palette and want to see how it stacks up against other options in the Too Faced collection.
Performance and Texture
While the palette's pigmentation is generally good, some shades, particularly the mattes, require layering for optimal intensity. The shades are buildable and blendable, but they lack the vibrant payoff I expected. Some shades are more subtle than the marketing suggests.
The texture of certain shades feels slightly stiffer than other palettes I’ve used, possibly affecting the ease of blending. The palette also features a pleasant, albeit unique peach scent that I describe as more akin to a gummy candy than a fresh peach.
Eye Makeup Look and Final Thoughts
The video showcases a makeup look created using the Sweet Peach palette. The tutorial demonstrates the application and blending techniques for different shades. The final look is soft, pretty, and very wearable, but maybe less bold than expected.

While the palette is undeniably cute and has a good shade range, the performance was a little underwhelming. The lack of vibrant color payoff and slightly stiff texture were notable drawbacks. The packaging is a major plus, but overall, the performance needs improvement. For those seeking a very vibrant, high impact palette this might not be your best option. Other Too Faced palettes may offer similar shades with a more pronounced color payout