This review pits two Maybelline concealers against each other in a head-to-head comparison: the Superstay Concealer and the Instant Age Rewind Eraser, both in the shade Deep Bronze. We'll explore the nuances of these popular products, examining their performance when used alongside the Maybelline Superstay Foundation Stick (also in Deep Bronze) to create a unified makeup look. This side-by-side analysis will delve into key aspects such as packaging, application, coverage, finish, and overall wearability, highlighting the subtle yet significant differences between these two seemingly similar concealers. The goal is to determine which concealer reigns supreme, taking into account individual preferences and desired coverage levels.The Deep Bronze shade is put to the test, revealing potential inconsistencies in color matching across the Maybelline product line. We'll investigate whether the shade discrepancies impact the overall makeup application and the final look. From initial application observations to the blended final result, this review meticulously compares coverage, texture, drying time, and ease of application. Ultimately, we'll determine whether the added cost and potentially faster application time of the Superstay Concealer justify its superior coverage, or if the Age Rewind Eraser provides a sufficient alternative for everyday wear.
Pros And Cons
- Full coverage
- Good pigmentation
- Dries quickly, requiring fast blending
- May not be necessary if you already own Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser
Read more: Top 5 Full Coverage Concealers You Need to Try
Product Overview and Packaging
This review compares the Maybelline Superstay Concealer in Deep Bronze to the Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser, also in Deep Bronze. Both concealers are used alongside the Maybelline Superstay Foundation Stick (Deep Bronze) for a cohesive look. The Superstay concealer comes in a sleek box showcasing a before-and-after image. It contains 0.23 fluid ounces (7ml), slightly more than the 0.2 fluid ounces (6ml) of the Age Rewind Eraser.
Packaging-wise, both are standard for Maybelline products, nothing particularly noteworthy or innovative.
Application and Initial Impressions
The Maybelline Superstay Multi-Use Foundation Stick is applied first as a base. The Age Rewind Eraser is applied to one side of the face, and the Superstay Concealer to the other. Initial observations note that the Age Rewind side appears slightly redder than the Superstay side, which seems more yellow-toned despite both being 'Deep Bronze'. This illustrates the color variation between different products despite their shared shade name.
The difference in application is also noted: the Superstay concealer seems to offer more full coverage compared to the Age Rewind which required less product for similar coverage.
Blended Results and Comparison
After blending, both concealers appear quite similar in terms of final look. However, the initial color difference remains evident in the final blended result. The Superstay concealer may have provided more full coverage initially. The reviewer notes both offer a matte finish, and the Superstay required faster blending due to quicker drying time.
Differences in pigmentation and application smoothness are observed. The Superstay concealer is described as being more pigmented but less smooth, while the Age Rewind provides a smoother application.
Final Verdict
The Maybelline Superstay Concealer offers noticeably more full coverage than the Age Rewind Eraser. While the final result appears quite similar after blending, the Superstay requires a quicker application due to its faster drying time. In terms of shade consistency, both products exhibit slight inconsistencies compared to the foundation in ‘Deep Bronze’.
Ultimately, if one already owns the Age Rewind Eraser, purchasing the Superstay Concealer isn't necessarily essential unless increased full coverage is a key priority. Both provide a matte finish suitable for everyday wear.