Choosing the perfect eyeliner can be a game-changer, and when it comes to felt-tip liners, Stila Stay All Day and NYX Epic Ink are top contenders. Both promise precise application and long-lasting wear, but with a significant price difference—$22 for Stila versus $9 for NYX—the question of value arises. This comparative review delves into a head-to-head assessment of these popular eyeliners. We examine their application, texture, longevity, and overall performance to help you decide which liner reigns supreme for your needs and budget.This in-depth comparison will explore the subtle differences between these two leading felt-tip liners. We'll analyze the application process, noting texture and ease of use, and carefully examine the resulting line quality and intensity. Finally, we'll assess the all-important longevity factor, observing smudging and lasting power to determine which eyeliner truly delivers on its "stay all day" promise. Ultimately, this review aims to empower you to make an informed decision based on your personal preferences and budgetary constraints.
Pros And Cons
- Good price ($9)
- Applies well
- Stays on lid all day
- Feels more wet than Stila
- Requires cleanup throughout the day due to smudging
- Easy to control
- Easy to apply wing
- Very black
- Stays all day
- No smudging
Read more: Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner: 5 Best Looks
Price Comparison and Initial Impressions
The Stila Stay All Day eyeliner, a high-end option, retails for $22, while the NYX Epic Ink Liner, a drugstore favorite, costs $9. This significant price difference begs the question: is the Stila worth the extra cost, or does the NYX provide comparable performance?
Both eyeliners are felt-tip liners, promising ease of application and precise lines. Initial observations suggest similar thin tips, hinting at comparable precision. The video reviews both from the perspective of someone who already regularly uses the Stila eyeliner.
Application and Texture Comparison
The Stila eyeliner is applied first to the left eye. The reviewer notes its ease of control for creating both a precise line and a wing. The black pigment is intense, and the application is smooth.
Next, the NYX Epic Ink Liner is applied to the right eye. The reviewer mentions the NYX liner feels more wet or liquidy compared to the Stila. The application is still smooth but with a noticeably different texture.
Side-by-Side Comparison and Longevity Test
A direct side-by-side comparison shows minimal visual differences in the final look. Both eyeliners create a similar intense black line, although the NYX application appears slightly thicker in this instance.
To further compare, both liners are applied to the back of the hand for a better texture and longevity assessment. The NYX liner displays a wetter consistency, while the Stila is smoother. The video also includes a follow-up several hours later to show lasting power.
Conclusion and Recommendation
Both the Stila Stay All Day and NYX Epic Ink liners perform admirably. The NYX liner offers impressive value at $9, providing a similar intense black color and lasting power as the Stila. However, the Stila's slightly drier consistency provides superior longevity without smudging.
Ultimately, the choice depends on individual priorities. If budget is a concern, the NYX liner is a great option, requiring only minor touch-ups throughout the day. For flawless, long-lasting wear with no smudging, the Stila Stay All Day is the premium choice, justifying its higher price tag.