This review dives deep into the Smashbox Always On Matte Liquid Lipsticks, putting ten shades to the test. We examine the formula, application, longevity, and overall wearability, comparing it to its predecessor, the Legendary line. The price point and noticeable reduction in product quantity are also addressed, providing a balanced perspective on this highly-anticipated launch. Prepare to discover if these liquid lipsticks live up to the hype and whether the changes justify the cost.This comprehensive review covers everything from the sleek (yet smaller) packaging and thicker-than-average formula to the impressive long-lasting wear and surprisingly comfortable feel. We'll detail the application process across various shades, assess its transfer-resistance during eating and drinking, and ultimately determine if these lipsticks are worth adding to your makeup bag. Get ready for a detailed analysis of a product promising all-day wear without compromising comfort.
Pros And Cons
- Fast drying time
- Non-drying formula
- Even application, no streaking or patchiness
- Long-lasting wear (8 hours claimed, performs well through snacks and drinks)
- Wears away evenly
- Easy to reapply without cakiness
- Transfer-proof (mostly, some transfer with meals)
- Precise applicator for clean lip lines
- Lightweight feel
- Significant wear in the center of the lips during meals
- Transfer-proof quality diminishes with meals
- Smaller amount of product (.13 fl oz) compared to Smashbox's Legendary Longwear Lip Lacquers (.2 fl oz)
Read more: Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk: 5 Must-Have Products
Packaging and Price
The Smashbox Always On Matte Liquid Lipsticks retail for $24 each, which is a standard price for high-end liquid lipsticks. The packaging is noticeably bulkier than their previous 'Legendary' line, holding only 0.13 fluid ounces compared to 0.2 fluid ounces in the older version. While the new packaging is sleek, the reduced product quantity for a similar price is a point to consider.
I noticed a considerable size difference when comparing it to their previous lip lacquer. The added plastic around the tube adds bulk, but ultimately this is just a cosmetic difference; the overall design remains fairly standard.
This difference in size and product quantity raises concerns, especially since I've heard rumors that Smashbox might be phasing out their Legendary line. If this is true, it might impact those who preferred the previous formula and volume.
Formula and Application
The formula is thicker than many liquid lipsticks I've tried, more comparable to Jeffree Star's velour liquid lipsticks. The consistency varied slightly between shades, with 'Celebrity Skin' being the most similar across the range.
Despite its thicker texture, it dries incredibly quickly, a huge plus for preventing smudging during application. This fast drying time is a major benefit for a long-lasting lipstick.
Interestingly, despite the matte finish and fast-drying time, I didn't experience any dryness or cracking on my lips. The application is smooth and even, free of streaking or patchiness in all ten shades tested.
Wear Time and Transfer Resistance
The lipstick claims 8-hour wear, and while it didn't quite last that long through full meals, it performed remarkably well. It endured snacking, drinking, and even direct lip contact with glasses.
The most significant wear occurred during meals, particularly in the center of the lips, which is typical for many long-lasting lipsticks. However, it faded evenly, without becoming blotchy.
The transfer-proof aspect is impressive, with minimal transfer, especially around the mouth’s perimeter. Even when some transfer occurred, it was manageable and easily touched up.
Overall Impression and Conclusion
The Smashbox Always On Matte Liquid Lipsticks are a winner. The application is effortless, the color payoff is excellent, and the comfortable wear is unmatched. The formula is non-drying and surprisingly lightweight, despite its impressive lasting power.
While the price point and reduced product volume might be a concern compared to the previous line, the overall performance makes them a worthwhile investment. They are amongst the best liquid lipsticks I've used, providing a truly impressive combination of long-lasting wear, comfortable feel, and seamless application.
In short, this product delivers on its promises of long-lasting wear, minimal transfer, and comfortable application. Despite the concerns regarding the reduced product quantity compared to the previous generation, the remarkable quality and user-friendly application more than make up for it. Highly recommended!