This review pits two popular Maybelline mascaras against each other: Sky High and Falsies Lash Lift. Both promise volume and lift, but which one reigns supreme, especially for those with stubborn, flat lashes? I put them to the test, focusing on their performance without the aid of an eyelash curler, a crucial step for my naturally downward-pointing lashes. My primary concerns were volume, lift, and longevity, with flaking being an absolute deal-breaker. This comparison delves into the wand design, application, initial results, and all-day wear, offering a detailed account of each mascara's strengths and weaknesses.The battleground is set: two contenders vying for the title of best mascara for flat lashes. We'll explore the differences in wand design, application ease, and the ultimate results achieved with each. Ultimately, this review aims to provide a clear and concise comparison, helping you decide which mascara best suits your needs. Discover which one delivers superior volume, lasting lift, and smudge-proof wear, ultimately determining the winner in this mascara showdown.
Pros And Cons
- Thin, flimsy wand coats lashes well
- Immediate lift
- Separates lashes
- No flaking or smearing after 12 hours
- Good volume after several hours of wear
- Holds curl well
- Doesn't provide much initial volume
- Provides more volume than Sky High
- Visible volume on lower lashes
- Holds curl well
- Larger wand may cause smearing
- Some smearing observed after application
Read more: Bobbi Brown Smokey Eye Mascara: 5 Must-Have Shades
Mascara Candidate Profile: My Flat Lashes
I have very fine, flat, and stubbornly downward-pointing lashes. They possess some length, but not much volume. My everyday routine involves lash curling before mascara application. For this comparison, however, I'll apply the mascaras without curling to showcase their individual performance.
I'm primarily looking for volume, followed by lift and then length. Flaking is a major no-no due to my oily skin type. A mascara that stays put all day is essential.
Maybelline Sky High Mascara: First Impressions
The Sky High mascara wand is thin and flexible, making it easy to reach and coat every lash. The initial application provides good separation and an immediate lift. While the volume isn't immediately overwhelming, I've found that many mascaras build volume throughout the day.
The Sky High mascara comes in two shades and a waterproof version. It retails for around nine dollars and promises full volume and limitless length.
Maybelline Falsies Lash Lift Mascara: First Impressions
The Falsies Lash Lift mascara wand is considerably larger and thicker than the Sky High wand. The initial application delivers significant volume, though it also resulted in some slight smudging. The packaging is also slightly different, with a more premium look.
This mascara retails for around ten dollars and promises dramatic volume and lifted lashes. It's been on the market for approximately nine months.
Side-by-Side Comparison and 12-Hour Wear Test
A direct comparison shows both mascaras provide similar results, with the Falsies offering slightly more volume, especially on the lower lashes. However, the Sky High mascara's thinner wand helps prevent smudging.
Throughout a 12-hour wear test, both mascaras showed minimal flaking or smudging. The Sky High mascara maintained its lift and slightly edged out the Falsies in terms of overall volume by the end of the day.
Conclusion and Verdict
Both Maybelline Sky High and Falsies Lash Lift mascaras perform admirably, providing decent lift and volume for flat lashes. The Sky High mascara, however, has a slight edge due to its superior ability to prevent smudging and maintain lift throughout the day.
While the price difference is minimal, the Sky High mascara's superior performance makes it the slightly better choice for those with flat lashes seeking all-day wear. Both are decent options, though.