Losing a beloved Beauty Blender is a makeup tragedy, but replacing it with an equally pricey option isn't always feasible. This review dives into the Sephora Collection Perfectionist Airbrush Sponge, a budget-friendly alternative to the iconic Beauty Blender. Driven by the need to find a cheaper replacement after a mold incident, the author explores this Sephora offering as a potential solution, hoping to achieve similar seamless blending results without breaking the bank. Their search initially led them to the highly-regarded Real Techniques sponge, but stock issues prompted a change of plans, leading to the unexpected encounter with the Sephora alternative.This honest review details the author's experience using the Sephora Perfectionist Airbrush Sponge, from initial impressions to its ultimate performance in everyday makeup application. Discover whether this affordable sponge lives up to the hype, or if it falls short of expectations. The author shares their candid thoughts on its blending capabilities, highlighting its shortcomings and ultimately deciding if the cost savings justify its underwhelming performance. Find out if the Sephora sponge is a worthy dupe, or just a costly mistake.
Read more: Top 5 Pink Makeup Sponges: Best Picks for Flawless Application
My Beauty Blender Mishap and the Search for a Dupe
My Beauty Blender, a birthday gift, met an unfortunate end due to my own carelessness. I stored it improperly, leading to mold growth. Replacing it with another Beauty Blender felt excessive at $26 CAD. That's when my search for a cheaper, comparable alternative began. The Real Techniques sponge was my top choice, praised as a dupe for its affordability and similar performance.
Finding the Real Techniques sponge proved difficult. My local Walmart consistently lacked stock, forcing me to explore other options. While online ordering is an option, I prefer to examine the product in person before purchasing.
This led me to Sephora, where I encountered a potential replacement: the Sephora Collection Perfectionist Airbrush Sponge.
First Impressions and Initial Use
The Sephora sponge initially felt promising, mimicking the texture and feel of the Beauty Blender. The packaging boasts claims of smooth application for liquid and cream makeup. However, my experience proved disappointing.

The sponge performed poorly. I tried blending concealer, but instead of blending, it primarily lifted the product off my skin. It failed to achieve the seamless finish I expected.

Using it over the past week only solidified my negative opinion. I found myself resorting back to using my fingers to even apply makeup, rendering the sponge completely useless.
Final Verdict and Recommendation
Despite its lower price point of $15 CAD compared to the Beauty Blender's $26 CAD, I wouldn't recommend the Sephora Collection Perfectionist Airbrush Sponge. Its poor blending capabilities outweigh any cost savings.
I plan to return the Sephora sponge and ultimately order the Real Techniques sponge online. While my search for a perfect Beauty Blender dupe continues, I advise skipping this product.
Ultimately, spending extra for a reliable blending tool is more worthwhile than purchasing an inferior and frustrating product that fails to deliver on its promises.