This review dives deep into the Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes mascara, exploring its performance in terms of length versus volume. We'll examine the unique aspects of the mascara's design, from its distinctive pink-hued tube and unusual flat brush, to its application and overall effect on the lashes. Comparisons will be drawn with a popular volumizing mascara to provide a clearer understanding of its strengths and weaknesses. Prepare to discover if this mascara lives up to the hype and whether it delivers the promised "push-up" effect.This in-depth analysis covers initial impressions, including the texture of the tube and the feel of the brush. We'll detail the application process, highlighting techniques for maximizing both length and lift. Finally, we'll offer a comprehensive conclusion, weighing the pros and cons and ultimately determining if the Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes mascara is a worthwhile addition to your makeup bag, particularly in comparison to other leading mascaras on the market.
Pros And Cons
- Gives length to lashes
- Creates a delicate, feminine, and flirty lash look
- Looks better with a full face of makeup
- Doesn't provide a lot of volume
- May require a separate mascara for lower lashes
- The wand's design may be initially unappealing
- Provides significant volume
- Creates a smoky look
Read more: Bobbi Brown Smokey Eye Mascara: 5 Must-Have Shades
First Impressions & Packaging
Upon first opening the Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes mascara, I noticed the unique pink lower portion of the tube. The texture felt slightly like it had a paper-like coating, which raised concerns about potential smudging with extended use. This is a personal preference, but the potential for dirt accumulation might be a concern for some.
The packaging itself is elegant, consistent with Charlotte Tilbury's branding. The rose gold accents and the sleek tube design are visually appealing. The overall presentation definitely adds to the luxurious feel of the product.
Wand & Bristle Design
The wand is a rubber bristle style, noticeably flat when viewed sideways. This design initially gave me some pause, as it differs from the more common long-comb style wands I usually prefer.
While the fine bristles are present, the flatness felt unusual. However, this design allows for precise application and helps to separate lashes effectively, despite the initial uncertainty.
Application & Results (Compared to Lancôme)
Applying the Charlotte Tilbury mascara, I initially noticed a lack of volume compared to my holy-grail Lancôme Monsieur Big mascara. However, it did provide noticeable length, especially when applied using a sideways motion from the lash base to tips.
A key application tip: Use the flat side of the wand to brush upwards, creating length and lift. This technique helps maximize the product's lengthening capabilities.
Lower Lash Application & Overall Impression
Applying the mascara to my lower lashes proved a little trickier due to the thin and flat brush. While it provided length, the volume was still less than what I achieve with my Lancôme mascara.
The Charlotte Tilbury mascara created a more delicate, feminine lash look. While it may not give the same dramatic volume, it delivers noticeable length and lift, resulting in a more natural appearance.
Final Verdict
Overall, the Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes mascara is a good mascara, particularly for those seeking length and a more natural, lifted look. It's not a replacement for volumizing mascaras like Lancôme Monsieur Big.
While the initial impression was somewhat underwhelming, the mascara's performance improved significantly when applied correctly and with a full face of makeup. I recommend trying it out and experimenting with application techniques to achieve your desired look.