Ever wish for effortless, precise lines that last all day? Our pencil eyeliner is your secret weapon. Forget smudging and fading – this creamy, long-lasting formula glides on smoothly, creating sharp wings or subtle definition. From smoky eyes to a classic cat-eye, this eyeliner and its built-in sharpener lets you unleash your inner makeup artist. It's the perfect addition to your makeup bag, transforming your everyday look with ease. Get ready to master the art of the perfect line!
Choosing the right product can be challenging given the wide array of options. To help navigate this, a selection process considers factors like ease of use, lasting power, color intensity, safety, and overall value for the price. This ensures that only top-performing items are recommended.
1. Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Black Gel Eyeliner (Long-lasting, Smudge-proof)
Intense black, waterproof, long-lasting, and surprisingly affordable.
- Highly rated
- Longevity
- Eyeliner quality
- Pigment quality
- Ease of application
- Glide
- Some controversy about
- Smudge resistance
- Value for money
- Waterproof
Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner in 001 Black delivers intense, long-lasting color impact. This ultra-smooth, creamy formula glides effortlessly onto the waterline or lid, creating a variety of looks from subtle definition to bold, goth glam. Its waterproof, smudge-proof, and sweat-proof properties ensure all-day wear, even in extreme heat or humidity – truly scandal-proof! Dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested, it's suitable for sensitive eyes. Achieve precise lines with the easy-to-apply pencil, experiencing the high-intensity color payoff and 24-hour wear this 0.04oz eyeliner provides.
The Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Eyeliner is a truly exceptional product, delivering intense, rich black color that stays put all day long. Users rave about its incredible staying power, even withstanding swimming, diving, and even hours of activity on hot days. The creamy texture makes application smooth and easy, creating a bold, dramatic look or subtle definition with just one stroke. Many describe the color as the deepest black they've found, perfect for creating contrast, particularly for those with medium brown eyes and dark hair. While some users noted minor smudging if applied too quickly and a need for a specialized sharpener, the overwhelmingly positive feedback highlights its exceptional performance and affordability compared to higher-priced brands. This waterproof eyeliner, perfect for the waterline, is a must-have for anyone seeking long-lasting, high-impact definition. Its ease of application and impressive staying power make it a worthy addition to any makeup bag.
- Brand: Rimmel London
- Color: Black
- Finish Type: Glossy
- Item Form: Pencil
- Rate: 4.3 / 23871
- Waterproof
- Smudge-proof
- Long-lasting
- Everyday makeup routine
- Special events/nights out
- Water sports/swimming
2. Revlon ColorStay Waterproof Eyeliner (2-pack, Black)
Bold color, all-day wear, and effortless glide!
- Highly rated
- Ease of application
- Eyeliner quality
- Color
- Some controversy about
- Durability
- Smudge resistance
- Value for money
- Water resistance
- Functionality
Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil (201 Black, 2-pack) delivers up to 24-hour smudge-proof wear, making it perfect for all-day bold looks. This waterproof eyeliner boasts a creamy, smooth application with a built-in sharpener for precise lines and a smudger for creating smoky effects. Its rich black color provides intense definition, whether you're aiming for a classic defined line, a dramatic winged look, or a sultry cat-eye. Available in 8 ophthalmologist-tested shades, this versatile eyeliner is a must-have for any makeup bag. The long-lasting formula and convenient features ensure your eye makeup stays flawless, from day to night.
This eyeliner pencil is a true game-changer! Users rave about its creamy, smooth application, delivering bold, vibrant color with just one swipe. The rich pigmentation, available in shades like black brown, ensures a long-lasting, smudge-proof finish – even on sensitive waterlines. Many appreciate its waterproof nature, making it ideal for those with watery eyes or who wear contact lenses. The retractable design eliminates the need for sharpening, adding to its convenience. While some users noted minor smudging in specific circumstances, the overall consensus highlights its exceptional staying power and ease of use, making it a top choice for everyday wear. This eyeliner is a must-have for achieving a perfect, all-day look, whether creating a subtle line or a dramatic wing.
- Brand: REVLON
- Color: BLACK
- Finish Type: Matte
- Item Form: Pencil
- Rate: 4.5 / 32293
- Up to 24-hour wear
- Waterproof and smudge-proof
- Built-in sharpener
- Everyday makeup routine
- Special occasions/events
- Water sports/swimming
3. Wet n Wild Kohl Eyeliner: Baby's Got Black - Intense Matte
Intense color, long-lasting wear, and surprisingly affordable!
- Highly rated
- Value for money
- Pigmentation
- Works well
- Ease of application
- Smoothness
- Look
- Some controversy about
- Longevity
- Quality
Unleash your inner makeup artist with the wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil in "Baby's Got Black." This intensely pigmented, creamy eyeliner delivers a smooth, long-wearing matte finish that's perfect for creating any look, from subtle everyday definition to dramatic smoky eyes. Its hyper-pigmented formula ensures rich, vibrant color payoff with every application. Loved by celebrities and makeup artists alike, this versatile, cruelty-free and vegan pencil offers exceptional value and performance, embodying wet n wild's commitment to accessible, high-quality beauty since 1979. Experience the difference of a truly iconic eyeliner.
The Wet n Wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil, particularly in shades like "Simma Brown" and deep black, consistently receives rave reviews for its exceptional quality and affordability. Users praise its creamy, hyper-pigmented formula, which glides on effortlessly and provides a long-lasting, bold matte finish. Many appreciate the eyeliner's impressive length, offering significant value for its low price point. Its versatility shines through, with users employing it for various looks, from everyday eyeliner to smoky eyes and even lip lining. The eyeliner's staying power is a major plus, remaining intact throughout the day, even on the waterline for many (though some note it may need touch-ups). While some users mention occasional melting or difficulty fitting it into standard makeup cases, these are minor drawbacks overwhelmingly overshadowed by the product's rich color payoff, ease of application, and exceptional value, making it a top choice for both makeup novices and experts alike. The cruelty-free and vegan aspects further enhance its appeal.
- Brand: wet n wild
- Color: Baby's Got Black
- Finish Type: Matte
- Item Form: Pencil
- Rate: 4.5 / 11371
- Rich, hyper-pigmented color
- Smooth, creamy application
- Long-wearing matte finish
- Everyday makeup routine
- Creating dramatic smoky eye looks
- Tightlining for a subtle enhancement
4. e.l.f. Satin Black Eyeliner Pencil with Sharpener
Effortless application, long-lasting color, and built-in sharpener!
- Highly rated
- Value for money
- Sharpener
- Eyeliner quality
- Works well
- Ease of application
- Application speed
- Some controversy about
- Quality
- Smudge resistance
Create precise, smoldering eyes with the e.l.f. Satin Eyeliner Pencil in Black. This creamy, pigmented 0.03 oz pencil delivers a beautiful satin finish with effortless application, gliding smoothly along your lash line, top and bottom. The built-in sharpener ensures a consistently sharp, precise tip for easy control, making creating any look from subtle to dramatic a breeze. As a 100% vegan and cruelty-free product, certified by Leaping Bunny, this eyeliner is a guilt-free addition to your makeup bag, offering professional-quality results at an affordable price. Experience the effortless application and long-lasting wear of this e.l.f. cosmetics essential.
This eyeliner is a fantastic find! Many reviewers praise its smooth application and rich, perfectly pigmented color, ideal for achieving precise lines, including a stunning cat-eye. The built-in sharpener in the lid is a huge plus, eliminating the need for a separate sharpener. Customers consistently highlight the product's long-lasting wear and excellent value for the price. One user even noted its suitability for those with blonde hair and blue eyes, emphasizing its non-excessive darkness. While one review mentioned that it's not waterproof, the overall consensus points to this eyeliner's exceptional quality and convenience. The ease of application and lasting power make it a highly recommended product, particularly for those seeking a reliable and affordable eyeliner.
- Brand: e.l.f.
- Color: ['Coffee']
- Finish Type: Satin Finish,Satin
- Item Form: Pencil,Creamy
- Rate: 4.4 / 3523
- Creamy, pigmented formula for smooth application
- Built-in sharpener for precision
- Cruelty-free and vegan
- Everyday makeup routine
- Creating a sharp winged eyeliner look
- Tightlining for a subtle eye enhancement
5. Maybelline TattooStudio Eyeliner: 36-hour waterproof, deep onyx.
Vibrant color, smooth glide, long-lasting wear—a true standout!
- Highly rated
- Eyeliner quality
- Color quality
- Ease of application
- Color
- Some controversy about
- Longevity
- Smudge resistance
- Functionality
- Sharpening ability
Create dramatic, long-lasting eye looks with the Maybelline TattooStudio Long-Lasting Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil in Deep Onyx. This waterproof eyeliner boasts 36-hour wear, ensuring smudge-proof definition all day and night. Its smooth gel pigments deliver intense color payoff with precise application, perfect for creating subtle lines or smoky eyes. The sharpenable pencil allows for customized control, making it ideal for various makeup looks, from classic to bold. As a leading makeup brand, Maybelline offers a wide range of complementary products, including eyeshadows, brow pencils, and mascaras, to complete your desired look. Experience the ultimate in lasting eyeliner performance with TattooStudio.
This eyeliner is a true standout, earning rave reviews for its vibrant color payoff and incredibly smooth application. Users consistently praise its long-lasting wear, describing it as a "long wear liner" that stays put for hours, even on the waterline. Many appreciate the rich, intense color achieved with just a couple of swipes, making it ideal for creating both dramatic and subtle looks. The formula glides on effortlessly, making application quick and easy. While some users noted that it's not easily smudged for a smoky effect (a feature some might see as a disadvantage depending on their desired look), its precision makes it perfect for sharp, defined lines. Although a few users experienced issues with sharpening or the pencil mechanism, the overwhelming consensus points to this eyeliner as a superior product offering exceptional value for its price. The overall experience is one of vibrant color, ease of use, and remarkable staying power, making it a favorite among users for various makeup styles.
- Brand: MAYBELLINE
- Color: 900 DEEP ONYX
- Finish Type: Matte
- Item Form: Gel Pencil
- Rate: 4.3 / 32936
- 36-Hour Wear
- Waterproof
- Sharpenable
- Everyday makeup routine
- Special events or nights out
- Creating precise and dramatic eye looks