Pat McGrath Permagel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil: Top 5 Must-Have Shades

Ever wished your eyeliner stayed put all day, through sweat and happy tears? Meet the Pat McGrath Permagel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil—your new best friend for effortlessly intense eyes. This richly pigmented, ultra-glide formula delivers a smudge-proof, long-lasting line, whether you're rocking a classic cat-eye or a smoky masterpiece. Forget touch-ups; this eye pencil's staying power is legendary. Prepare for compliments and all-day confidence. Its creamy texture makes application a breeze, and the range of intensely pigmented shades opens a world of eye makeup possibilities.

This list prioritizes items based on a rigorous evaluation process. Factors considered include color intensity, ease of use, longevity, finish type, and comfort. The goal is to provide consumers with a curated selection of high-performing products, ensuring a superior user experience.

1. Pat McGrath PermaGel Eye Pencil: Black Coffee

Pat McGrath PermaGel Eye Pencil: Black Coffee

Achieve effortlessly smoldering eyes with Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil in BLK COFFEE, a rich espresso brown shade. This 1.2g gel eyeliner boasts an ultra-smooth, ultra-glide application that seamlessly glides onto the eyelid, offering ample time for blending and smudging before setting for up to eight hours. The intensely pigmented formula ensures vibrant, saturated color without skipping or dragging, making it perfect for creating precise lines or smoky effects. Safe for contact lens wearers, this long-lasting eyeliner is a must-have for achieving professional-looking eye makeup that lasts all day.

This eyeshadow palette, a vibrant collection of richly pigmented shades perfect for creating a stunning eye look, exceeded my expectations in terms of color payoff. While the packaging on my particular unit could have been improved, the product itself is a dream to work with. The smooth, blendable formula made achieving a precise winged liner, thanks to its finely milled texture, incredibly easy. I highly recommend this eyeshadow palette for anyone looking to elevate their eye makeup game.

  • Brand: Pat McGrath Labs
  • Color: BLK COFFEE
  • Finish Type: Matte
  • Item Form: Pencil
  • Rate: 1 / 1
Outstanding features:
  • Ultra-smooth, glide-on application
  • Blendable formula with long-lasting wear (up to 8 hours)
  • Rich, saturated color payoff
Context of use:
  • Everyday makeup
  • Smoky eye look
  • Quick and easy eyeliner

2. Pat McGrath PermaGel Glide Eye Liner: Xtreme Black

Pat McGrath PermaGel Glide Eye Liner: Xtreme Black

Introducing Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil Eyeliner in Xtreme Black, the ultimate precision tool for creating any eye look. This ophthalmologist-tested eyeliner boasts a unique, long-wearing (up to 8 hours!), waterproof formula that glides on effortlessly without tugging. Its intensely pigmented, matte black shade delivers rich saturation, while the customizable texture allows for both precise lines and smoky effects. Combining the ease of a pencil with the impact of a gel, the PermaGel offers smudge-proof wear, perfect for creating bold, graphic liner art or soft, blended looks. Suitable for contact lens wearers, this exceptional eyeliner ensures all-day comfort and drama.

  • Brand: Pat McGrath Labs
  • Color: Xtreme Black
  • Finish Type: Matte
  • Item Form: Pencil
Outstanding features:
  • Long-lasting & waterproof (up to 8 hours)
  • Intensely pigmented matte black
  • Precise gel-like application
Context of use:
  • Creating sharp, graphic eyeliner looks
  • Achieving a long-lasting, smudge-proof eyeliner for all-day wear
  • Making a smoky eye look

3. Pat McGrath PermaGel Ultra Glide Eyeliner: Xtreme Black

Pat McGrath PermaGel Ultra Glide Eyeliner: Xtreme Black

Unleash your inner artist with Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Glide Eyeliner Pencil in Xtreme Black (202). This intensely pigmented, phthalate-free pencil delivers a smooth, effortless application, creating a striking matte black finish that lasts all day. Its full coverage formula flawlessly defines and accentuates the eyes, providing a smudge-proof, long-lasting look that's as bold as it is dependable. Experience the luxury and precision of this professional-grade eyeliner, perfect for achieving everything from a subtle wing to a dramatic smoky eye. The creamy texture ensures comfortable wear, while the superior staying power guarantees your look remains flawless from dawn till dusk.

This long-lasting eyeliner delivers intense, deep black color that stays put all day. Users rave about its staying power and rich pigmentation, making it perfect for creating dramatic or subtle eye looks. While some users reported issues with clumping or difficulty with removal in specific instances, the overwhelmingly positive feedback highlights its exceptional longevity and vibrant color payoff. The product’s ease of application and impressive wear time are key selling points, ensuring a flawless finish that lasts.

  • Brand: Pat McGrath Labs
  • Color: Black
  • Finish Type: Matte
  • Item Form: Pencil
  • Rate: 4 / 10
Outstanding features:
  • Smooth, easy glide application
  • All-day smudge-proof matte finish
  • Full coverage, intense black color
Context of use:
  • Creating a sharp, dramatic winged eyeliner look
  • Achieving precise, defined eyeliner for a classic look
  • Intensifying eye makeup with a long-lasting, smudge-proof black liner

4. Pat McGrath PermaGel Glide Eye Pencil (BLK Coffee)

Pat McGrath PermaGel Glide Eye Pencil (BLK Coffee)

Unleash your inner artist with Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil in BLK Coffee, a deep brown eyeliner offering unparalleled versatility. This professional-grade pencil boasts intense pigmentation for rich, seamless application, whether you're creating sharp, precise lines or a smoky eye. Its long-lasting, waterproof formula ensures smudge-proof wear for up to 8 hours, defying even the most demanding conditions. Experience the effortless glide of the gel-like texture and achieve a stunning satin vinyl finish, showcasing the opulent opacity of this exceptional eyeliner. The PermaGel formula caters to both matte and pearlescent preferences, making BLK Coffee a must-have addition to any makeup bag.

    Outstanding features:
    • Rich Pigmentation
    • Long-Wearing (8 hours)
    • Versatile Finish Options
    Context of use:
    • Everyday makeup routine
    • Special occasion makeup
    • Creating dramatic eye looks

    5. Pat McGrath PermaGel Glide Eye Pencil: Blitz Blue

    Pat McGrath PermaGel Glide Eye Pencil: Blitz Blue

    Unleash your inner artist with Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil in Blitz Blue, a mesmerizing indigo with blue pearl shimmer. This 1.2g/0.42oz eyeliner boasts an ultra-smooth gel formula that glides effortlessly onto the lids, offering ample time for blending and smudging before setting for a stunning, 8-hour wear. Experience the luxurious, rich color payoff without skipping or dragging, creating a precise line or a smoky effect with ease. Safe for contact lens wearers, this PermaGel pencil delivers professional-level results with its exceptional glide and long-lasting performance, making it a must-have addition to any makeup bag.

    • Brand: Pat McGrath Labs
    • Color: BLITZ BLUE
    • Finish Type: Metallic
    • Item Form: Pencil
    Outstanding features:
    • Ultra-smooth, easy glide application
    • Blendable formula with long-lasting wear (up to 8 hours)
    • Rich, vibrant color payoff
    Context of use:
    • Creating a bold, vibrant eye look
    • Achieving a precise, long-lasting winged liner
    • Smudging for a smoky indigo eye