Pat McGrath Labs MatteTrance lipsticks have generated considerable buzz, but do they live up to the hype? This review dives deep into the experience of purchasing, using, and comparing these luxury lipsticks. We explore the challenges of acquiring these highly sought-after shades, examining the opulent packaging, hefty price tag, and shipping costs. We then delve into the performance of two specific shades, Full Panic 5 and Obsessed!, analyzing their texture, pigmentation, and wear time.This in-depth review investigates the much-discussed formula, its velvety matte finish, and its comfort level. We also compare the MatteTrance shades to several drugstore and high-end dupes, assessing how closely they match the coveted Pat McGrath formula and color payoff. Finally, we offer a balanced perspective, weighing the undeniable luxury and performance against the accessibility issues and price point to determine if the MatteTrance lipstick truly justifies its considerable cost and reputation.
Pros And Cons
- Insane pigmentation (completely opaque in one swipe)
- Proper matte finish (no shine)
- Velvety texture
- Lightweight and comfortable (often forgotten it's being worn)
- Wears nicely (even fading, no bleeding or patchiness)
- Reapplies well
- Can feel slightly dry
- High price
- Difficult to obtain
Read more: Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk: 5 Must-Have Products
Shopping Experience & Packaging
Purchasing Pat McGrath Labs MatteTrance lipsticks directly from the website was a challenge. Shades sold out incredibly fast, even hours after the launch. The pricing is steep; individual lipsticks are $38 USD, while sets are offered at varying prices. Shipping costs add significantly to the total expense, making it a luxury purchase.
The packaging is luxurious, arriving in a gold sleeve adorned with sequins. While visually stunning, the sequins are a bit of a nuisance. The lipstick bullets themselves are beautifully designed with gold detailing and a weight that reflects the price point. However, the closure is a standard click, not the expected magnetic closure.
Shades, Formula & Pigmentation
I chose the shades Full Panic 5 and Obsessed!, both exhibiting the same impressive formula. Reviews suggest formula variations exist across shades. Full Panic is a vibrant fuchsia with cooler undertones, and Obsessed! is a red-leaning orange that varies depending on skin tone. Both are intensely pigmented, achieving full opacity in a single swipe.
The texture is velvety matte, but not completely transfer-proof. A slight slip is noticeable when lips are pressed together. They are lightweight and comfortable, but might feel slightly drying for some, particularly those with dry or chapped lips. The formula doesn't settle into lip lines, but it also doesn't actively hydrate them.
Dupe Comparison
Several dupes were tested to find alternatives with similar color and formula. Mac Lady Danger was the closest match to Obsessed!, although slightly more vibrant and orange-toned. For Full Panic, Kat Von D Bachelorette was a strong contender, with a very similar color and matte finish. Other brands like Charlotte Tilbury, NARS, and Rimmel offered similar colors but different textures and levels of opacity.
Wear Test & Conclusion
After a five-hour wear test including a meal, the lipstick faded evenly, with minimal transfer or bleeding. Reapplication was smooth. While impressively long-lasting for a matte lipstick, it did feel slightly drying over time, requiring lip balm for extra comfort.
Overall, the Pat McGrath Labs MatteTrance lipsticks are luxurious and high-performing. The intense pigmentation, comfortable lightweight feel, and decent wear time justify the hype for many users despite the price and accessibility challenges. While dupes exist, none perfectly replicate the combination of color payoff, comfort, and long wear that makes these lipsticks truly special.