Discover the captivating shades of Maybelline Superstay Matte Ink Liquid Lipsticks! This comprehensive review dives deep into ten standout colors, showcasing their unique characteristics and versatility across diverse skin tones. From classic nudes and warm browns perfect for everyday wear, to bold reds and vibrant pinks that command attention, we explore the range's impressive pigmentation and long-lasting formula. Each shade is meticulously swatched and analyzed, providing valuable insights to help you find your perfect match.This detailed review covers a spectrum of shades, including the versatile "Fighter" and "Caramel Collector," the naturally enhancing "Delicate" and "Revolutionary," the statement-making "Peacekeeper" and "Overseer," and the universally flattering "Savant" and "Enchanter." We also examine the suitability of "Coco Connoisseur" and "Ring Leader" across different complexions. Prepare to be inspired as we uncover the exceptional quality and diverse options within this highly-rated lipstick line.
Pros And Cons
- Completely matte
- Transfer-proof
- Budge-proof
- Very long-lasting
- Highly pigmented
- Affordable
Read more: Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk: 5 Must-Have Products
Brown & Orange Hues: Fighter & Caramel Collector
The first two shades showcased are 'Fighter,' a beautiful brownish-orange with warm undertones, and 'Caramel Collector,' a similar brownish tone with warm orange undertones. Both shades offer a classic 90s brown vibe, making them incredibly versatile and flattering on a wide range of skin tones.

These shades are perfect for those who enjoy a more classic and timeless look. They transition seamlessly from day to night, making them essential additions to any makeup collection.

Nude & Pink Perfection: Delicate & Revolutionary
Moving on to the pink and nude shades, 'Delicate' is a lovely pinkish nude perfect for fair to medium complexions, creating a natural, everyday look. 'Revolutionary' offers a different take on pink, blending nude tones with a subtle lilac or purple undertone, making it another versatile choice.

These two shades are great for those who prefer softer, more natural looks or those who want a touch of color without it being too bold. They're also great options for a more subtle, everyday makeup routine.

Red & Bold: Peacekeeper & Overseer
'Peacekeeper,' from the Brooklyn Blush collection, is a striking brick red shade that complements various skin tones. This is perfect for those who are looking for a statement lip color suitable for special occasions.

'Overseer,' on the other hand, is a vibrant, festive red, offering a beautiful and bold look that's just as versatile as the other shades reviewed. It truly enhances any complexion.
Everyday & Versatile Browns & Pinks: Savant, Coco Connoisseur, & Enchanter
'Savant' is a personal favorite, a versatile pink shade for everyday wear that suits various skin tones. 'Coco Connoisseur' is a rich brown that adapts well to different complexions, appearing as a dark brown on fair skin and a milk brown on dusky skin.

'Enchanter' is another highly-recommended pink shade, offering exceptional versatility across all skin tones. It’s a perfect everyday option that complements all complexions without being overwhelming.

Specific Shade Considerations: Ring Leader
Finally, 'Ring Leader' is a vibrant pink shade most suited to fair to medium skin tones. On deeper skin tones, it may appear washed out and less flattering. Therefore, skin tone should be considered when choosing this shade.

Overall Review & Conclusion
The Maybelline Superstay Matte Ink Liquid Lipsticks offer a wide range of shades, from classic nudes and browns to vibrant pinks and reds. These lipsticks are highly pigmented, long-lasting, and transfer-proof, making them a great value for the price.
While some shades are more versatile than others (depending on skin tone), the collection provides ample choices for a variety of tastes and preferences. The formulas are consistently impressive, offering a comfortable matte finish without drying out the lips excessively. Overall, this is a highly recommended lipstick line.