Ever wished for eyes that pop? We found the secret: kohl eyeliner. This isn't your grandma's pencil; we're talking rich, intense color that lasts. From subtle smudged looks to dramatic winged liner, kohl eyeliner—with its creamy texture and easy application—lets you effortlessly create any eye makeup masterpiece. Think smoky eyes, sharp lines, or a gentle, defined gaze. Get ready to unleash your inner makeup artist! Experiment with different shades and techniques—the possibilities are endless.
The selection process prioritizes items meeting stringent quality benchmarks. Factors such as ease of use, durability, and overall performance were carefully considered to ensure only top-performing options are included. This curated list aims to simplify the decision-making process for consumers seeking superior products.
1. wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil - Rich Hyper-Pigmented Color, Smooth Creamy Application, Long-Wearing Matte Finish Versatility, Cruelty-Free & Vegan - Baby's Got Black
Intense color, long-lasting wear, and surprisingly affordable!
- Highly rated
- Value for money
- Pigmentation
- Works well
- Ease of application
- Smoothness
- Look
- Some controversy about
- Longevity
- Quality
Unleash your inner makeup artist with the wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil in "Baby's Got Black." This intensely pigmented, creamy eyeliner delivers a smooth, long-wearing matte finish that's perfect for creating any look, from subtle everyday styles to dramatic, smoky eyes. Its hyper-pigmented formula ensures rich, bold color payoff with a single stroke, while the kohl pencil format allows for versatile application. Cruelty-free and vegan, this Wet n Wild essential—a favorite of celebrities and makeup artists—provides professional-quality results without the hefty price tag, making high-impact beauty accessible to everyone.
The Wet n Wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil, particularly in shades like "Simma Brown" and deep black, consistently receives rave reviews for its exceptional quality and affordability. Users praise its creamy, hyper-pigmented formula, which glides on effortlessly and delivers bold, long-lasting color—a matte finish that stays put all day. Many appreciate its versatility, using it for everything from a simple liner to creating dramatic smoky eyes or even as a lip liner. The extended length of the pencil provides excellent value, exceeding the size of typical drugstore eyeliners. While some users note minor drawbacks like occasional melting or difficulty fitting into smaller makeup cases, the overwhelmingly positive feedback highlights the eyeliner's rich color payoff, ease of application, and impressive staying power. Its cruelty-free and vegan formulation is also a significant plus for ethically conscious consumers. Overall, this eyeliner offers a remarkable combination of performance and price, making it a top choice for both beginners and makeup enthusiasts.
- Brand: wet n wild
- Color: Baby's Got Black
- Finish Type: Matte
- Item Form: Pencil
- Rate: 4.5 / 11371
- Rich, hyper-pigmented color
- Smooth, creamy application
- Long-wearing matte finish
- Everyday makeup routine
- Creating dramatic smoky eye makeup
- Tightlining for a subtle enhancement
2. Natural Black Eyeliner Powder: Intense, Long-lasting, Smudge-proof
Experience the allure of ancient Egypt with our handmade, 100% natural black powder eyeliner. This intensely pigmented, long-lasting formula delivers a smudge-proof, waterproof finish that lasts all day. Made with gentle, skin-friendly ingredients, free from harmful chemicals, it's perfect for sensitive eyes. Its versatility shines – use it as eyeliner (both inner and outer), eyeshadow, or even eyebrow powder, creating a variety of captivating looks. Inspired by Egyptian beauty secrets, this unique powder eyeliner provides intense color and a captivating, seductive effect, ensuring your eye makeup remains flawless and charming from dawn till dusk.
This eyeliner and its accompanying application tool are a game-changer for achieving the perfect winged or Cleopatra-inspired eye look. Users rave about its ease of use and ability to create precise lines, resulting in stunning, dramatic eyes. While a small amount of powder may fall during application, this minor inconvenience is easily outweighed by the superior results and the overall ease of creating a flawless winged liner. The product's precision makes it a valuable addition to any makeup kit.
- Brand: DTCTQNG
- Color: Black
- Finish Type: Matte
- Item Form: Powder
- Skin Type: All
- Rate: 3.8 / 10
- 100% Natural Ingredients
- Intense, Long-Lasting Color
- Smudge-Proof & Waterproof
- Everyday makeup
- Special occasions (weddings, parties)
- Historical/theatrical makeup
3. Nefertari Egyptian Natural Powder Eyeliner (Handmade)
Intense pigment, long-lasting, but mastering application takes practice.
- Highly rated
- Color
- Durability
- Application
- Ease of application
- Eye irritation
- Pigmentation
- Comfort
- Some controversy about
- Smudge resistance
Experience the luxury of ancient Egypt with Nefertari 100% natural Egyptian eyeliner, a handmade kohl powder crafted from the same pure gum and olive oil formula used by the living during antiquity. This lead-free, allergy-free eyeliner, packaged in a traditional olive wood container reminiscent of pharaohs' treasures, is made entirely from frankincense gum, soaked in olive oil, then carefully burnt and collected. Unlike the lead-based kohl used in mummification, Nefertari's formula is gentle enough to leave on overnight, offering a safe and historically accurate way to achieve the iconic Egyptian eye look. Enjoy the richness and safety of this timelessly beautiful cosmetic, a true testament to ancient Egyptian beauty secrets.
This highly pigmented, natural Kohl eyeliner delivers stunning results. Users rave about its intense color payoff and the ease of achieving a natural, rustic look, whether applied precisely with the included applicator or softly smudged for a smoky effect. Many appreciate the clean ingredient list, free from irritants, making it comfortable even for sensitive eyes. While some users initially found the applicator's thickness challenging and experienced minor smudging or fallout, these were easily mitigated with careful application techniques like tapping off excess powder before use and employing a setting powder underneath the eyes. The long-lasting wear, described as lasting all day for some, coupled with the rich color, makes this product a worthwhile investment. The unique olive wood applicator, while initially unusual for some, allows for both precise lines and effortless blending. Although some mention a small amount of product in the container, many cleverly repurposed the product into reusable containers, maximizing the value. The overall consensus points to a beautiful, effective eyeliner offering a superior experience compared to conventional options, ideal for creating both sharp and naturally smudged looks.
- Brand: Nefertari
- Color: brown
- Finish Type: Natural
- Item Form: Powder
- Rate: 4.2 / 598
- 100% Natural Ingredients (Frankincense & Olive Oil)
- Lead-Free & Safe for Eyes (No Removal Needed)
- Traditional Egyptian Formula & Packaging
- Historical reenactments/events
- Luxury beauty rituals/self-care
- Ancient Egypt themed parties/events
4. LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Kajal Longwear Kohl Eyeliner Pencil - Soft Black Kohl - Caffeine and Vitamin E - Smooth & Blendable Liner - Built-In Sharpener
Creamy, long-lasting color; effortlessly glides on, stays put all day.
- Highly rated
- Ease of application
- Color
- Longevity
- Eyeliner quality
- Softness
- Glides on smoothly
- Some controversy about
- Smudge resistance
- Sharpener
Experience the Laura Geller New York Kajal Longwear Kohl Eyeliner Pencil in Soft Black, a luxurious eyeliner designed for effortless application and long-lasting wear. Its smooth, blendable kohl formula, infused with Vitamin E and caffeine, glides on seamlessly, hydrating lids while reducing puffiness. Achieve intense, richly pigmented color with skip-free strokes, perfect for creating bold looks or subtle smudges. The built-in sharpener ensures precision every time, making this eyeliner a must-have for any makeup bag. Whether you prefer a classic defined line or a smoky eye effect, this versatile pencil delivers, offering 15 shades to complement any eye color.
Laura Geller's eyeliner pencils deliver exceptional performance and ease of use, making them a top choice for various ages and skin tones. Users consistently praise the creamy, smooth application, noting how easily the pencil glides on, creating a precise line or a softly blended effect. The color payoff is rich and vibrant, with options ranging from deep charcoal to soft browns like Smokey Quartz and Toasted Kohl, offering subtle shimmer for a beautiful, complimentary look. Many reviewers, even those with mature or hooded eyes, found the staying power remarkable; the liner lasts all day without smudging, fading, or transferring, even after workouts or in warm, humid climates. While some users initially found the pencil's softness resulted in over-application (easily remedied with a lighter touch), this very softness contributes to the ease of blending. The built-in sharpener is a convenient addition, though some suggest using an external sharpener to minimize product waste. Overall, this eyeliner pencil receives rave reviews for its long-lasting wear, beautiful colors, and effortless application, surpassing even more expensive competitors and making it a worthwhile investment.
- Brand: LAURA GELLER NEW YORK
- Color: 04 Soft Black
- Finish Type: Satin
- Item Form: Pencil
- Rate: 4.3 / 4205
- Long-lasting, smooth application
- Infused with Vitamin E and Caffeine
- Built-in sharpener
- Everyday makeup routine
- Creating a smoky eye look
- Defining the waterline
5. SUGAR Kohl Of Honour Intense Black Kajal: Long-lasting, lightweight.
Long-lasting, intensely dark, smudge-proof eyeliner—a beauty must-have!
- Highly rated
- Eyeliner quality
- Ease of application
- Longevity
- Glide
- Pigmentation
- Value for money
- Some controversy about
- Smudge resistance
- Quality
Introducing SUGAR Cosmetics Kohl Of Honour Intense Kajal in 01 Black Out – the ultimate black kajal for intense, all-day wear. This 100% opaque, ultra-creamy kajal boasts a long-lasting, budge-proof formula that glides on effortlessly, creating precise lines in a single stroke. Its wax-based, paraben-free composition ensures a smudge and transfer-resistant finish that lasts for 12 hours. Enjoy the lightweight feel and intense pigmentation of this Made-in-India product, complete with a self-sharpening design for convenient application. Experience the Kohl Of Honour – intense definition, all day long.
This intensely pigmented kohl eyeliner pencil delivers exceptional value and performance. Users rave about its incredibly smooth application, creating a dark, rich line with minimal effort, even on the sensitive waterline. Many found it lasted all day, even with watery eyes or humid conditions, significantly outperforming other brands, including Maybelline Colossal. The creamy texture makes blending easy, while its impressive staying power (reportedly up to 12 hours!) makes it perfect for both everyday wear and special occasions. While some users noted minor smudging or fading after extended wear, the overall consensus highlights its superior longevity and dramatic effect, transforming eyes with a simple application. The convenient twist-up format adds to its practicality. This eyeliner is a true game-changer, especially for those with hooded eyes or who struggle to find a long-lasting waterline liner.
- Brand: SUGAR Cosmetics
- Color: 01 Black Out (Black)
- Finish Type: Matte
- Item Form: Pencil
- Rate: 4.5 / 2276
- 12-hour smudge-proof wear
- Intensely pigmented, one-stroke application
- Self-sharpening, no sharpener needed
- Everyday makeup routine
- Special occasions/events
- Intense eye makeup looks