This review dives into the Eco Tools Perfecting Blending Duo Sponge, a two-sponge set featuring a larger green sponge and a smaller lime-yellow one. Each sponge boasts a unique design with flat sides ideal for larger and smaller facial areas, and a rounded top for seamless blending. We put both sponges to the test, using them with various makeup products, from foundation and concealer to setting powder, to determine their effectiveness and compare them to other popular makeup sponges on the market, such as the Beautyblender and Real Techniques sponges. Our detailed analysis explores the performance of each sponge individually, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses and ultimately determining their overall value.This comprehensive review examines the application techniques, texture, and absorption capabilities of both sponges, focusing on how effectively they blend different makeup formulas. We explore whether the Eco Tools duo offers a comparable—or even superior—experience to higher-priced alternatives. The results provide a clear picture of whether this affordable set delivers on its promise of perfecting blending, and ultimately, whether it deserves a place in your makeup bag.
Read more: Top 5 Pink Makeup Sponges: Best Picks for Flawless Application
Unboxing and First Impressions
The Eco Tools Perfecting Blending Duo Sponge comes with two sponges: a larger, green sponge and a smaller, lime-yellow sponge. Both sponges have unique shapes with flat sides for larger areas and smaller areas of the face, and a rounded top for seamless blending.
The larger sponge is significantly more absorbent and becomes much softer when wet. The smaller sponge, however, feels firmer and doesn't expand as much when dampened, resulting in less squishiness.
The packaging suggests both sponges can be used wet or dry, but the review shows that the larger sponge works best when dampened. Proper dampening is crucial for optimal application and blending.
Foundation Application Test
The reviewer uses a combination of L'Oréal Infallible foundation shades, one matte and one satin, for the foundation application test.
The larger, flat side of the green sponge was used for larger areas of the face, while the smaller flat side was used for under-eye application.
The rounded top of the sponge is used to seamlessly blend edges and contours, achieving a smooth and natural finish.
Concealer and Powder Application
Tarte Shape Tape concealer is applied and blended using the smaller lime-yellow sponge, although the reviewer found this sponge less effective and more difficult to use due to its firmness.
The larger green sponge is preferred for setting powder, demonstrating its superior blending capabilities compared to the smaller sponge.
The reviewer notes that the smaller sponge, while smaller, doesn't perform as well due to its less bouncy texture, leaving a patchy finish.
Final Verdict and Comparison
The larger green sponge receives a 10/10 rating for its exceptional blending performance with foundation, concealer, and powder. Its unique shape and soft texture make it highly versatile.
The smaller lime-yellow sponge is less impressive due to its firmness, resulting in a less seamless application, particularly with powder.
Compared to other brands like Real Techniques and Beautyblender, the Eco Tools sponge (the larger one) offers a superior blend of affordability, performance and unique design, making it a valuable addition to any makeup collection. The overall value for money at $9.99 is excellent, especially considering the quality of the larger sponge.