Choosing the perfect concealer can be a game-changer in your makeup routine. Drugstore options often offer impressive quality at accessible prices, but navigating the vast selection can be overwhelming. This head-to-head comparison dives deep into two popular contenders: Covergirl Trublend Undercover and Maybelline Superstay 24-Hour Concealer. Both boast full coverage and long-lasting wear, but their performance varies in several key aspects. We'll examine their application, texture, longevity, and overall finish to help you determine which best suits your needs.This detailed review will analyze each concealer's applicator, shade range, and claimed benefits. We’ll put them to the test through real-world wear, comparing their performance throughout the day. From initial application to lasting power, we'll explore the nuances of each formula, considering factors like creasing, settling, and overall wearability. Ultimately, we aim to provide a comprehensive comparison to assist you in making an informed decision and finding your ideal drugstore concealer.
Pros And Cons
- Full coverage
- Matte finish
- Easy to blend
- Lightweight formula
- Lasts all day
- Vegan and cruelty-free
- Wide shade range (30 shades)
- More affordable than Maybelline option
- Larger bottle size (0.33 fl oz)
- Some minor separation after 8 hours of wear, particularly around the nose
- Full coverage
- Lightweight
- Waterproof, transfer and smudge resistant
- Cooling sensation upon application
- Separation around nose and smile lines earlier than Covergirl concealer
- Smaller shade range (16 shades)
- More expensive than Covergirl option
- Smaller bottle size (0.23 fl oz)
Read more: Top 5 Full Coverage Concealers You Need to Try
Concealer Showdown: Covergirl Trublend Undercover vs. Maybelline Superstay
Today, we're pitting two popular drugstore concealers against each other: the Covergirl Trublend Undercover and the Maybelline Superstay 24-Hour Concealer. Both claim full coverage and long-lasting wear, but how do they stack up in a real-world test?
The Covergirl concealer boasts a large, fluffy doe-foot applicator and comes in an impressive 30 shades. It's marketed as lightweight, matte, and vegan-friendly. The Maybelline Superstay, on the other hand, features a more tapered applicator and a slightly smaller shade range of 16 shades. It promises waterproof, smudge-proof, and 24-hour wear.
To ensure a fair comparison, I applied a light layer of foundation before applying each concealer to one half of my face. I used a lighter shade under my eyes and a slightly darker shade to cover blemishes. This allowed for a clear assessment of coverage and lasting power.
Application and Initial Impressions
The Covergirl Trublend Undercover's large applicator made for quick and even application. The formula was surprisingly thin and lightweight, blending seamlessly despite offering substantial coverage. It didn't crease or cake, even with multiple layers.
The Maybelline Superstay's tapered applicator provided precise application, particularly around the eyes. While also lightweight, it had a slightly cooler sensation upon application and felt very comfortable on the skin. The coverage was comparable to the Covergirl, providing a flawless finish.
The Wear Test: 8 Hours Later
After approximately eight hours of wear, both concealers held up remarkably well. The Covergirl concealer showed slightly less separation around the nose and smile lines compared to the Maybelline, which experienced some separation earlier in the day.
While both concealers settled into my smile lines to some degree, the Covergirl's formula seemed to resist creasing and separation for a longer period. Overall coverage remained consistent across both sides of the face, masking blemishes effectively.
Final Verdict
In this head-to-head comparison, the Covergirl Trublend Undercover Concealer edged out the Maybelline Superstay. While both offer excellent full coverage and blend beautifully, the Covergirl offered slightly better longevity and a smoother, brighter finish. It maintained its flawless appearance for a longer duration.
The Covergirl concealer also has a more extensive shade range and a lower price point, making it a more compelling option overall. However, the Maybelline Superstay is a strong contender and might be preferable for those prioritizing a specific applicator style and 24-hour wear claims.
Ultimately, both are excellent drugstore concealers that deserve consideration. The choice depends on individual preferences and priorities but for overall value and performance, Covergirl Trublend Undercover takes the win for me.