Choosing the perfect eyeshadow palette can be overwhelming, especially with so many options available. Tarte Cosmetics' Tartelette Juicy palettes offer a tempting trio of choices: the Mini, Medium, and Large (or "Big Juicy"). Each boasts a vibrant collection of shades promising juicy, blendable color payoff, but which one reigns supreme? This comprehensive comparison delves into the specifics of each palette, examining their unique color stories, quality, and overall value. We'll explore the differences in shade selection, pigmentation, and texture to help you determine which Tartelette Juicy palette best suits your makeup needs and budget. Whether you're a seasoned makeup artist or a casual enthusiast, this review will guide you to making an informed decision.This in-depth analysis covers everything from the smaller, travel-friendly Mini palette to the expansive Large palette, offering a detailed side-by-side comparison. We'll dissect the pros and cons of each, considering factors such as price, shade range, pigmentation, and blendability. Discover which palette boasts the most unique shades, which offers the best value for your money, and ultimately, which one will become your new go-to for achieving stunning eye looks. Get ready to dive into the world of Tartelette Juicy and find your perfect match!
Pros And Cons
- 12 eyeshadows
- Same size as other Tartelette palettes
- Shades are nearly identical to the Big Juicy palette but slightly creamier
- Condensed version of the Big Juicy palette
- No new shades compared to Big Juicy
- Dark brown shade ('Euphoric') is patchier than in the Big Juicy palette
- 20 eyeshadows
- Good for everyday looks with pinky tones
- Many shades blend well together
- Being discontinued
- 9 shades
- More berry-toned shades than the other two palettes
- Currently on sale
- Least favorite quality-wise; feels dry
- Fewer shades that are similar to the other two palettes
Read more: 5 Stunning Cool-Toned Eyeshadow Palettes You Need
Introducing the Tartelette Juicy Palettes
Tarte Cosmetics offers three variations of their popular Tartelette Juicy eyeshadow palettes: the Mini, Medium, and Large (or 'Big Juicy'). This review compares their color stories, quality, and overall value to help you decide which palette is right for you. Each palette features a unique blend of juicy, vibrant shades perfect for creating a range of looks, from everyday neutral to bold berry tones.
The Mini Juicy palette is a smaller, more affordable option, perfect for travel or those looking to try the formula. The Medium Juicy palette is a standard size, providing a balance between versatility and portability. The Large Juicy palette boasts the largest selection of shades, ideal for those who enjoy a wider range of options.
Color Story and Shade Comparison
The Mini Juicy palette offers a unique selection of darker berries and plums not found in the larger palettes. This makes it ideal for those seeking richer, more intense looks. The Medium and Large palettes share almost identical shade selections, with the Large palette including additional neutral and transition shades.
The Medium palette lacks the unique berry tones of the Mini palette but includes twelve shades, matching many colors from the larger palette. The Large palette has 20 shades, offering more versatility and options for creating complex looks, and features additional neutral shades absent in the Medium palette. This makes the Large palette ideal for those who prefer a larger selection of colors to play with.
Quality and Performance
While all three palettes are made in the USA, the Mini Juicy palette felt drier compared to the Medium and Large palettes. The Medium and Large palettes showed very similar quality and blendability. The dark brown shade ('Euphoric') in the Medium palette had slightly less pigmentation and blended less smoothly than the same shade in the Large palette.
Overall, the pigmentation is very good in all palettes and they performed well on the eyes, creating seamless blends with minimal fallout. The creaminess was only slightly more noticeable in the Medium palette compared to the Large, although both were very similar in this aspect. This suggests the slight difference might be due to the age of the reviewer’s Large palette.
Pricing and Value
The Mini Juicy palette retails for $29 (often on sale), the Medium for $39, and the Large for $45. While the price difference between the Medium and Large palettes may seem small for the increased number of shades, it aligns with the pricing of other Tartelette palettes. The Large palette offers the best value due to its greater number of shades and overall versatility.
Considering the shared shades between the Medium and Large palettes, buying the Large is more beneficial if you don't mind the bigger size. The Mini palette is a good option for trying the formula or as a travel-friendly size but lacks some shades found in the other palettes.
Conclusion and Recommendation
The best Tartelette Juicy palette ultimately depends on your individual needs and preferences. The Large Juicy palette offers the best overall value and shade selection, while the Medium palette provides a more compact option with almost identical shades to the large one. The Mini Juicy offers a unique berry-focused color story.
For those seeking a diverse range of shades and maximum value, the Large Juicy is the clear winner. The Medium is a great alternative if you want a more manageable size. The Mini serves as a good starting point for exploring the Tartelette Juicy formula or for travel. However, if you're on a budget, waiting for a sale on either the Mini or Medium palette could save some money.