This review delves into the Clinique Pretty Easy Eyeliner, a pen-style eyeliner promising effortless application and long-lasting wear. Priced at around $21, it's positioned in the moderate-to-high-end market segment. We'll explore whether this eyeliner lives up to its claims of being waterproof, smudge-proof, and easy to use, examining its application, longevity, and overall performance. We'll also discuss any potential drawbacks, such as color intensity and shelf life.This comprehensive review will cover all aspects of the Clinique Pretty Easy Eyeliner experience, from the initial unboxing and first impressions of the sleek packaging and applicator, to a detailed account of its application and wear throughout the day. We'll assess its performance under various conditions to determine its true waterproof and smudge-proof capabilities. Finally, we'll offer a balanced perspective, weighing the pros and cons to help you decide if this eyeliner is the right choice for your makeup routine.
Pros And Cons
- Tip never loses its shape
- Can create thick or thin lines
- Applies quickly
- Waterproof
- Long-lasting (all day)
- Doesn't shine
- Dries quickly
- Doesn't smudge or transfer
- Indicates expiration date (6 months)
- Color is described as 'charcoal' rather than a deep black
Read more: Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner: 5 Best Looks
Packaging and First Impressions
The Clinique Pretty Easy Eyeliner arrives in a sleek box, promising a luxurious feel from the start. The price point is around $21, which is moderate for a high-end eyeliner. First impressions are important, and the packaging certainly sets a positive tone.

The pen-style applicator is immediately appealing; it’s easy to grip and control, a significant factor for precise application. The thin, precise tip allows for both thin lines and bold looks.
Application and Wear Test
Application is surprisingly smooth and quick, making it ideal for busy mornings. The formula glides on effortlessly, creating a consistent line with minimal effort. The eyeliner dries quickly without smudging or transferring.

I tested the eyeliner's longevity and waterproof claims throughout the day and it lived up to expectations. Even after several hours and exposure to some humidity, there was no smudging or fading. The formula remained consistent throughout.
Pros and Cons
This eyeliner boasts many advantages, including its long-lasting wear, smudge-proof formula, quick-drying time, and precise applicator. The waterproof quality is a major plus. The ease of application is also noteworthy.
However, one minor drawback is the color. While described as black, it is slightly less intense than some users might prefer, and it is closer to a dark charcoal. Also, the six-month expiration date requires consistent use.
Final Verdict
Overall, the Clinique Pretty Easy Eyeliner is a solid performer. Its impressive waterproof and smudge-proof qualities make it a reliable choice for all-day wear. The ease of application and long-lasting wear are significant advantages.
Despite the slightly less-intense-than-expected black color, the pros significantly outweigh the cons, particularly for those seeking a practical, reliable eyeliner that won't let you down. This eyeliner stands out due to its longevity and waterproof features. I highly recommend it for everyday use.